Opinions please

Place for all to talk about STO and for 12th Fleet public information exchange. This forum is open to public view.

Moderator: Command

User avatar
Husker
Posts: 7857
Joined: Tue April 3rd, 2012 11:59 am
Captain: Husker
@handle: @Ashman7286
Location: Dunno ¯\(°_o)/¯

Opinions please

Post by Husker »

So i want genuine opinions, does this look any good???

I haven't done much to the actual mountain section yet. I've been concentrating on the ground and rocky area along the back and also blending the ship in to the mountain to make it look like it's been there a while. Also no skid marks yet.

Image
User avatar
Mike
Posts: 2377
Joined: Fri February 19th, 2010 1:25 pm
@handle: @MikeGTC
Location: Belgium

Re: Opinions please

Post by Mike »

Wow looks good so far m8!

I would weather the nacel a bit more, looks to 'new' compared to the saucer.
Place the broken of nacel next to the ship? Like itbroke of over time?

Also, post it on trekworks!
=/\= ================================= =/\=
Lieutenant Mike
United Federation of Planets
The 12th Fleet Science Division Zeta Squad
USS Illustrious NCC 198206
Ready on Arrival
=/\= ================================= =/\=
User avatar
Husker
Posts: 7857
Joined: Tue April 3rd, 2012 11:59 am
Captain: Husker
@handle: @Ashman7286
Location: Dunno ¯\(°_o)/¯

Re: Opinions please

Post by Husker »

Yeah the other nacelle is going underneath the saucer section like it broke off and slid alongside the ship.

I haven't really weathered it much yet. I sprinkled some bits over the ship to see how it would look but it definitely needs more.

Also more of that vegetation hanging from the overhang above the saucer to look like vines, then i'll carry that bushy look up and over and just work my way along.
User avatar
Sysil
Command Advisor
Posts: 5628
Joined: Tue August 31st, 2010 3:21 am
Captain: Sysil
@handle: @siyanlis
Location: Starbase Valhalla

Re: Opinions please

Post by Sysil »

This looks real nice!
Image

Image Image
Image Image Image Image Image
User avatar
Prototype_No.98
Posts: 1914
Joined: Fri May 4th, 2012 2:15 pm
Captain: Bryce
@handle: @Protosovereign
Location: UK

Re: Opinions please

Post by Prototype_No.98 »

I think its a real improvement to the Abrams Ent. :guffaw:
User avatar
cmdraftbrn
Posts: 2889
Joined: Tue August 25th, 2009 3:47 am
@handle: @cmdraftbrn

Re: Opinions please

Post by cmdraftbrn »

could use more scarring on the saucer and nacelles. but looks good
Capt. JJJH Schimdt
Engineering Division Alpha Team
UFP 12th Fleet
USS Lusitania NCC-93015 Nebula Class

Patrolling

Infected/Cleared, Cure/Cleared, Kithomer Accord/Cleared, Terradome/Cleared
Foundry FED: Player Concept Housing*, Great Raid (part 1), Training Ground 2.0, Ultimate Deathmatch, Redshirt Zombie, All Hallows Eve

*Down for Repairs
Sorotia
Inactive
Posts: 201
Joined: Fri July 25th, 2014 10:46 pm
@handle: @Sorotia

Re: Opinions please

Post by Sorotia »

Despite hating that abomination! :P

I'd say it looks good.
User avatar
Goldy
Posts: 25458
Joined: Mon May 2nd, 2011 8:26 pm
Captain: Moi :P
@handle: @Stuart_Gold
Location: Reviving Khan...

Re: Opinions please

Post by Goldy »

Looks good bud :beer:
ImageImageImageImageImage
Goldy & Mirra do not believe in a No Win Scenaro...
Biography of Gold & Crew - Captain & Crew Logs of the USS Mavrix
User avatar
QorDaq
Posts: 3844
Joined: Wed March 23rd, 2011 3:15 am
Captain: QorDaq
@handle: @QorDaq

Re: Opinions please

Post by QorDaq »

Okay, so here goes, you asked for it! Heh...

In terms of the model itself, the weathering, the overall look of the base, and so on, and considering that you have said yourself that you are not done, I'd say you are headed in the right direction and it all looks good individually.

What I am having a hard time with is figuring out the story that is being told by the piece.

For example: Is the Saucer meant to be "Slicing into" the side of the cliff-face or is that where the ship came to rest after being stopped by the cliff?

I ask because currently, with the damaged edge of the Saucer meeting the exact face of the cliff, it looks (abstractly), like a pizza cutter wedged into a block of cheese. This, to me, does not seem like what would happen after a massive chunk of machinery fell from the sky and slid (however far), until meeting a mass large enough to stop it's momentum.

I would expect either that the Saucer--if strong enough to take the impact--would displace the terrestrial materials in it's path (ala Riker crashing the E in Generations), or that the Saucer would crumple and break apart where it meets the stronger formation of rock face. Likely a combination of the two.

Then over time, the foliage and other detritus would build up around the structure of the ship naturally (which is the part you said you have not gotten to yet).

I am also curious if the neck of the ship could sustain the weight of the saucer over a prolonged period of time.

In short, individually the elements are coming along nicely, and clearly you have the skill to make them look good because they already do... I, personally, am just looking to the diorama to tell me a story about how the ship got to be where it is, and what has happened to it since.

I hope that makes sense? I'm definitely not saying your work is not good, in terms of detail I think it's going to look terrific.

maj!
So much for Photo Bucket.
User avatar
cmdraftbrn
Posts: 2889
Joined: Tue August 25th, 2009 3:47 am
@handle: @cmdraftbrn

Re: Opinions please

Post by cmdraftbrn »

(ala Riker crashing the E in Generations)
that was troi and the D cheif
Capt. JJJH Schimdt
Engineering Division Alpha Team
UFP 12th Fleet
USS Lusitania NCC-93015 Nebula Class

Patrolling

Infected/Cleared, Cure/Cleared, Kithomer Accord/Cleared, Terradome/Cleared
Foundry FED: Player Concept Housing*, Great Raid (part 1), Training Ground 2.0, Ultimate Deathmatch, Redshirt Zombie, All Hallows Eve

*Down for Repairs
Post Reply