USS Challenger

Place for all to talk about STO and for 12th Fleet public information exchange. This forum is open to public view.

Moderator: Command

Post Reply
Hatch
Posts: 918
Joined: Thu November 18th, 2010 7:25 pm
@handle: @hatchmo252
Location: Texas

USS Challenger

Post by Hatch »

For those that have read the books, do you find it strange that STO would put Geordi at the helm of the USS Challenger when in the books, Scotty is the captain?

Not taking anything away from it, love that La Forge is back and am enjoying the Nexus Mission. Just a question since STO decided to put the USS Challenger into the mix.
=/\= =========================== =/\=
Vice Admiral Hatch
Engineering Division
DV Red Headed Stepchild
Current Location: Wherever there is a subspace vortex
Current Assignment: Blowing the Borg to Hell
12th Fleet, United Federation Of Planets

=/\= =========================== =/\=
User avatar
Khaldore
Posts: 109
Joined: Fri April 25th, 2014 6:57 pm
Captain: Khaldore
@handle: @khalfyreshyft
Location: Helena, MT

Re: USS Challenger

Post by Khaldore »

I don't find it particularly strange, since Cryptic seems to pick and choose from canon and non-canon sources alike. And, according to "Indistinguishable from Magic" (via Memory Beta's summary):
Spoiler (click to show/hide)"Subsequently, Scotty chooses to retire from Starfleet, become a civilian specialist, and promotes Geordi La Forge to captain, giving him command of the Challenger."

and

"After stealing away to the Challenger, Scotty holds the ship until the Tomalak's Fist travels back through the fold and destroys the Starfleet vessel to un-fold space and close the opening. But at the instant the ship implodes, Scotty is transported away -- unsure if he'll survive inside the toroidal continuum fold, but prepared for the possibility of death."

So technically, the Challenger shouldn't even exist anymore, going by the TNG Relaunch. Since Cryptic also ignored the ST: Destiny books... *shrug* seems to make sense they'd base the idea of Geordi captaining the Challenger on VOY: "Timeless" instead.
Either way, I dig the fact LeVar Burton agreed to do some VO work. I can't help but go into "Reading Rainbow" mode whenever I hear him speak. :)
=/\= =========================== =/\=
Captain Khaldore Fyreshyft, Beta Squadron Captain
Current Location:
Alpha Quadrant, Badlands Battlezone
Current Assignment: USS Antonia (Typhon Command Escort Carrier, NX-80479)
12th Fleet, United Federation Of Planets
=/\= =========================== =/\=
ImageImageImageImage
ImageImageImage
Hatch
Posts: 918
Joined: Thu November 18th, 2010 7:25 pm
@handle: @hatchmo252
Location: Texas

Re: USS Challenger

Post by Hatch »

hmmm true, my bad, I forgot about the VOY episode.
=/\= =========================== =/\=
Vice Admiral Hatch
Engineering Division
DV Red Headed Stepchild
Current Location: Wherever there is a subspace vortex
Current Assignment: Blowing the Borg to Hell
12th Fleet, United Federation Of Planets

=/\= =========================== =/\=
Post Reply