Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Place for all to talk about STO and for 12th Fleet public information exchange. This forum is open to public view.

Moderator: Command

Forge04
Posts: 3743
Joined: Mon August 30th, 2010 11:33 am
Captain: Forge04
@handle: @Forge04

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Forge04 »

They cloned Darth Maul, or just remade him with the Force.

Midichlorians are in the blood, Darth Vader lost much of his power in the Force when he became so mechanical. And I'm sure there was plenty of Vader DNA around to use. Why didn't Yoda or Obi-Won just make another Anakin? Let him have the memories of the original. Padme's already gone. He can see his failure of what would happen when you fall to the Dark side.

And all the crazy with clones? Luuke and cho boath? Why didn't Starkiller II go stark raving nuts?

These kinds of plot holes are the complete reason why Star Trek will always be better than that other sci-fi thing.
Semper Paratus - Always Ready

Image
Semper Invictus, Semper Vigilans - Ever Invincible, Ever Watchful
Image
User avatar
Hohndo
Posts: 4634
Joined: Tue February 8th, 2011 10:33 am
Captain: Hohndo, Hazel
@handle: @Hohndo

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Hohndo »

Starkiller 2 killed Starkiller 1..or so we are made to believe.

Force Unleashed 2, you played the original one.

To be honest..that game should have stopped at one..didn't need a follow up..it actually fit pretty well.
Forge04
Posts: 3743
Joined: Mon August 30th, 2010 11:33 am
Captain: Forge04
@handle: @Forge04

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Forge04 »

Either way, those extremely force sensitive clones weren't crazy.
Semper Paratus - Always Ready

Image
Semper Invictus, Semper Vigilans - Ever Invincible, Ever Watchful
Image
Loki
Posts: 2978
Joined: Thu June 9th, 2011 2:10 am

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Loki »

Supposedly according to the lore its almost impossible to clone a sane Jedi. In the grand Admiral Thrawn Trilogy its explained that Sidious tried and failed this namely with a Jedi named Jorus C'both.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jorus_C'baoth

The books actually explained it quiet well and they are probably the some of the best ones out of the pile of SW books to hit the shelves over the years. Lucas did ok all these and the author Timothy Zahn is probably the very best writer Lucas had for Star Wars.

This clone idea did carry over to the Force Unleashed two game as was already mentioned here, so unfortunately its almost impossible to clone a sane Jedi. :cry:
User avatar
Hohndo
Posts: 4634
Joined: Tue February 8th, 2011 10:33 am
Captain: Hohndo, Hazel
@handle: @Hohndo

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Hohndo »

This is a spoiler warning for those that had not finished the Force Unleashed 2..or if you even care.
I did this ending from the get-go on my first play through..this is when the game got really interesting, I feel like if this would have been the canon ending, it would have been better.

The game never explained midi-chlorian rate, George Lucas never liked that part of the EU.

And purely because I thought this fight was awesome..
User avatar
Toval
Posts: 4258
Joined: Sat December 18th, 2010 10:16 am
@handle: @Tovalmorgan
Location: North Texas

Re: Star Wars: The Biggest Plot Hole in History

Post by Toval »

Forge04 wrote:These kinds of plot holes are the complete reason why Star Trek will always be better than that other sci-fi thing.

I'll see your claim and raise you a http://www.moviemistakes.com/tv3008?singletype=plothole
Former Vice Admiral of Logistics & Supply

Image
Post Reply