The 12th Fleet: Starbase Valhalla

Air_Force_Man12 wrote:Crap! The Super Star Destroyer is beast! I'm sure if it was a fight between Star Trek and Star Wars. That ship alone could cause twice the damage of Wolf 359!

Meh.. a quantum spread across the bridge will take it out... all bulk no bite

Spicy_Mchaggis wrote:

Air_Force_Man12 wrote:Crap! The Super Star Destroyer is beast! I'm sure if it was a fight between Star Trek and Star Wars. That ship alone could cause twice the damage of Wolf 359!

Meh.. a quantum spread across the bridge will take it out... all bulk no bite

Hmmm I'm not so sure about that... Star Wars ships have Shields like Star Trek Ships do. Just a different design. The TIE Fighters how ever, we could ram every single one of those and not have a scratch. lol The Super Star Destroyers, I can imagine would deal some punishment.

Good Stuff!

Air_Force_Man12 wrote:

Spicy_Mchaggis wrote:

Air_Force_Man12 wrote:Crap! The Super Star Destroyer is beast! I'm sure if it was a fight between Star Trek and Star Wars. That ship alone could cause twice the damage of Wolf 359!

Meh.. a quantum spread across the bridge will take it out... all bulk no bite

Hmmm I'm not so sure about that... Star Wars ships have Shields like Star Trek Ships do. Just a different design. The TIE Fighters how ever, we could ram every single one of those and not have a scratch. lol The Super Star Destroyers, I can imagine would deal some punishment.

I've followed a heated star wars vs star trek argument once and the conclusion was that apart from the death star star wars ships are generally inferiour to star trek federation ships, but star wars ships can travel much faster. I'm not sure if star wars would be able to beat the borg though, should they ever be infaded...

Borg jedi would surily be the end of us all...

lol ya a whole fleet of star trek ships would be able to

Probably, but a Super Star Destroyer will probably have some friends as support..

Lethe wrote:Probably, but a Super Star Destroyer will probably have some friends as support..

Well.. if you put those vs the Borg collective... I think the outcome is predetermained already.

Only 1 borg drone floating through space might be enough already to mean the end of that star wars fleet. An entire fleet of borg cubes would probably cut up their entire army pretty quickly and assimilate the rest.

Just think if they assimilation the crew of the super star destoryer and learned the loacation of the cloning factorys....They could creat a endless armory of clones. If you thought they were bad now just wait tell they get to the kamino.....LOL

Hold on, you're talking about a single borg cube taking out a super star destroyer?

Executor class Super Star Destroyer (Vader's flagship)
Length: 19km
Crew: 280,000, plus 1,500 gunners
Armament: 2,000 turbolaser cannons, clustered in fire-groups of 8 (250 clusters)
2,000 heavy turbolaser cannons, clustered in fire-groups of 8 (250 clusters)
250 Concusion Missiles
250 Heavy Ion Cannons
500 point defense laser cannons
plus 144 TIE series starfighters.

Imperial Class Star Destroyer (Standard ship of the Imperial Fleet)
Length: 1.6 km
Crew: 37,000
Armament: 8 Octuple barbette Turbolaser cannons (8 barrelled turbolaser cannon arranged 2 rows of 4)
5 Heavy turbolaser batteries
30 Turbolaser batteries
20 Heavy Ion Cannons
plus 72 TIE series starfighters

Compare to star Trek

Sovereign class:
Length: 685 m
Crew: 885
Armament: 14 Type-XII Phaser Arrays
5 torpedo launchers (3 fore, 2 aft)

Defiant class:
Length: 120 m
Crew: 40
Armament: 4 Pulse Phaser Cannons, 4 torpedo launchers (2 fore, 2 aft)

Akira class:
Length: 465 m
Crew: 500
Armament: 6 Type-X Phasers, 3 torpedo launchers (2 fore, 1 aft)
40 Kaneda Class Space Superiority Fighters

Klingon Bird of Prey (B'Rel):
Length: 88 m
Crew: 14
Armament: 2 Disruptor banks, 1 torpedo launcher

K'Tinga battlecruiser:
Length: 215 m
Crew: 392
Armament: 8 disruptor banks, 2 torpedo launchers (1 fore, 1 aft)

Vor'Cha Class Attack Cruiser:
Length: 480 m
Crew: 1900
Armament: 16 disruptor banks, 3 torpedo launchers (2 fore, 1 aft)

and finally: Borg Cube:
Length: 3 km
Crew: 640,000
Armament: 36 Programmable weapons arrays, 12 focused neutron beams, 24 tractor beam emitters

Now unless there is a huge difference in weapon power from one series to the next, the Executor class would demolish all, and a Borg Cube vs Imperial Star Destroyer would be a straight up good fight.

i was talking about a fleet of borg cubs....but also if you remeber the borg ships can regenrate you learn that in voyager and TNG